Youth & Child

Scouting Builds Resilience for Life

The Scouting effect … what parents and leaders see every day

Resilience enables people to thrive and take on all that life has to offer, including the inevitable challenges. It’s about knowing our strengths and calling on them when needed.

Scouts empower young people to make decisions, take the lead and learn by doing, giving them a safe space where they can work with others to plan and embark on their own adventures, indoors and out. By building resilience in young people, Scouts are empowering them to be able to learn from their mistakes and to understand that failing is okay – it’s an integral part of the learning journey.

In 2019, Scouts Australia partnered with Resilient Youth Australia to explore the impact of Scouting on young Australians. Youth members across the country participated in the Resilience Survey, and after months of analysis, the results are in, and they show what Scouts, parents and Leaders see every day as youth members grow towards their potential.

It’s official – Scouting and resilience go hand in hand – the data proves it.

What is the Resilience Survey?

The Resilience Survey, developed in partnership with the UniSA Justice and Society at the University of South Australia benchmarked the responses of young people aged 8-18 who attend Scouts with those around the country who do not, pointing to the positive impact of Scouting.

It asked Scouts 75 multiple choice questions on a range of areas including their strengths, life satisfaction, hopefulness, coping style, mental health and risk and protective behaviours.

Read More about The Scouting Effect

What Were the Findings?

Check out the report: The Scouting Effect

and download the key finding posters :

• Scouts v Non-Scouts
• Percentage Difference

Active and Inactive Young Australians

An Independent Review of Research into Enablers and Barriers to Participation in
Sport, Active Recreation and Physical Activity among Children and Adolescents.

The purpose of this review is to identify what is known about barriers and enablers of participation in physical activity (including sport and active recreation) among children and young people aged 3-18 years, living in Australia. It has been compiled at the request of the NSW Office of Sport and primarily for consideration by the Committee of Australian Sport and Recreation Officials (CASRO).  Read More

Citation
Bellew, B., Rose, C., Reece, L. Active and Inactive Young Australians. An Independent Review of Research into Enablers and Barriers to Participation in Sport, Active Recreation and Physical Activity among Children and Adolescents. Produced for the NSW Office of Sport by the SPRINTER Research Group, Prevention Research Collaboration, Charles Perkins Centre, The University of Sydney, 2020.

Mindfulness in nature holds promise for wellbeing of at-risk children

An article from Education HQ on the possibility of improving kid’s mental health by combing therapy and adventure.

Dr Danielle Tracey and her colleagues Dr Gray, Dr Truong and Dr Ward of Western Sydney University sought to address this gap through a study using acceptance and commitment therapy alongside adventure therapy. The new interdisciplinary approach aims to promote the wellbeing of children with challenging behavioural and or emotional needs.

The program is based on interactive and outdoor activities. These included themed nature walks and the use of metaphors to help children identify anger, games working with knots to develop problem solving skills, and the minefield game in which students verbally guide their blindfolded teachers though an imaginary minefield to build trust and respect.

As Tracey explained, “The heart of adventure therapy is using the outdoors and experiential learning to deal with psychosocial difficulties.

Source: Education HQ

Stealing their Childhood

‘We’re not just stealing their childhood, but crushing it’

As I carried around a sobbing kindy child this morning as he cried for his mum (first time ever away from her) wrapped around me like a baby koala and totally overwhelmed by this strange new place called ‘school’ I had to wonder …

Who on earth genuinely believes these precious little ones need rotations, formal structure and ‘academic rigour’ at such a young age?

Do children today live in environments that are too safe? What does having some level of risk mean for the development of the child? Have we become so risk-averse that children are now developing problems because of a risk-free environment? If so, what can we do, and what risks are “good risks”

Griffin Longley at TEDxPerth

Why Walking Is So Good for Parents, Toddlers, and the Cities Where They Live

Planning and managing cities has become one of humanity’s defining challenges, yet it is hard to know how to plan for what a city needs now and in the future at the same time. What can we measure to determine if a city is functioning well for its residents today and is likely to live up to its full potential in the long run?

One answer: The daily life of a toddler.

Learning from Trees

Life Lessons for Future Generations
This report explores the skills and attributes children need in order to help them deal with future challenges. It combines Australian and international peer-reviewed academic research with the results of a snapshot survey of 200 teachers. The survey was designed and commissioned by Planet Ark and conducted online by consultants Kimberlin Education in April 2017

Australian children lack the basic movement skills to be active and healthy.

Just as children need to be taught their ABCs to read and write, they also need to be taught fundamental movement skills.

Fundamental movement skills (FMS) such as running, jumping, throwing and kicking, to provide the strongest foundation for a physically active lifestyle. Children who are proficient at FMS are more likely to be physically active and have adequate cardiorespiratory fitness, and are less likely to be overweight or obese compared with children who are not proficient. In addition, FMS-proficient children are more likely to become adolescents who are more active and with higher cardiorespiratory fitness levels.

Download 

Written by L. M. Barnett, L. L. Hardy, D. R. Lubans, D. P. Cliff, A. D. Okely, A. P. HillsE and P. J. Morgan on behalf of the Physical Activity and Sedentary Behaviour Stream of the Australasian Child and Adolescent Obesity Research Network (ACAORN)

Published online 18 July 2013

Determinants of Childhood Adiposity

Energy is required for growth, but the increased incidence of childhood obesity over recent decades indicates the difficulty children have in maintaining an ideal energy balance in the contemporary setting.

The impact of residential experience on primary school pupils

Lobbying for greater opportunity for young people to participate in Learning Outside the Classroom needs hard evidence. However, too little convincing evidence is available. On retiring, I had time to gather more evidence and embarked on a three year study of residential adventure education, the area in which I had spent the whole of my career.

Much research on outdoor learning carried out in the UK is qualitative – understandably, since it can provide an in-depth, rich description of what is happening. However, that is not sufficient and it is clear that, in order to get our message across to decision makers, some quantitative evidence is essential. My research therefore used mixed methods and this article explains both the qualitative and the quantitative findings in an attempt to encourage greater use of mixed methods in outdoor education research.

It focused on the impact of adventure-based residentials on primary school pupils. Two sets of numerical data were gathered. The first was simply used to set the scene. This was a simple survey of 260 English primary schools, with the sample chosen in a way that allows generalisation to all English primary schools.

Surprisingly, no fewer than 95% of English primary schools had offered at least one residential experience to their pupils who moved on to secondary school in 2011. The statistical uncertainty in that figure is plus or minus 5%. In view of the recent economic situation, it is interesting that the figure of 95% is considerably higher than the most recent reliable figure of 86% in 2004. Unsurprisingly, there was a significant correlation between the extent of residentials offered and the proportion of free school meals – the poorer the school’s catchment area, the fewer residentials were offered. This is a helpful finding from the perspective of lobbying for greater opportunity for all young people to experience the benefits of LOtC.

To follow the scene-setting survey, the core of the quantitative part of the study was a survey to gather pupils’ perceptions of the impact the experience had had on them. A total of 232 9-11 year old pupils completed a questionnaire to assess the impact that the residential had on them. Completed questionnaires were analysed using a statistical process that identifies the underlying variables in a set of data. This showed that there were four components to the impact, each of which had a good degree of statistical reliability:

• the impact of living with others,
• the impact of challenge,
• the impact of developing new relationships with teachers,
• the impact of learning about oneself.

For some of the pupils, these components of impact were compared with two separate indicators of behaviour change. One was the change in classroom attainment over the period following the course. The other was a measure of social and emotional progress.

Classroom attainment was measured before and after the residential using teachers’ formative assessments in reading, writing and maths. Two of the impact components, living with others and teacher relationships, showed a significant correlation with the improvement in pupils’ classroom attainment. This is a very exciting finding. However, a correlation does not in itself show that the residential causes the improvement in attainment – to demonstrate that requires more work and the final paragraph of this article invites readers to help with that work.

Social and emotional progress was measured by a self-perception questionnaire. There was a significant correlation between the perceived impact of living with others and the reduction in adverse emotional symptoms. The opportunity was also taken to compare the pre-course and post-course social and emotional indicators. There was a predictably strong and significant improvement in prosocial (co-operative and helpful) behaviour. However, there was also an interesting unpredicted finding – there was a significant reduction in self-perceived hyperactivity. This finding does not of course say anything about causality but it does suggest an interesting area for future research.

Turning to the qualitative part of the research, this consisted of a series of interviews with headteachers and parents to get their perception of how a residential impacts on pupils. Responses suggested that the complexity of the situation leads automatically to the emergence of new behaviour, including a sometimes dramatic step-change in self-confidence. Interviews showed that many factors contribute to the impact of a residential, including:

• new experiences, e.g. new activities and living with others 24 hours a day,
• excitation – an increase in energy levels caused particularly by two key energizing influences: the element of challenge and; the social dimension,
• a catalytic effect caused by the affective or emotional nature of the experience,
• a cementing effect caused by the memorable nature of the experience,
• the fact that the reward is intrinsic – personal satisfaction has a self-motivating effect.

However, the most interesting finding was the way in which all these factors combine in a holistic way to catalyse the emergence of new behaviour. Complexity theory was used to cast new light on the process. There is insufficient space here to go into much detail but complexity theory suggests that, in a system where there are many simple components interacting with each other, the system acts in a non-deterministic way. In other words, it is impossible to describe the outcomes in terms of cause and effect.

Such a system has some unexpected characteristics – one is that changes that take place are often non-linear, meaning that outcomes do not vary smoothly with the inputs but instead, small inputs can provoke large changes. A second, particularly exciting characteristic of a complex system is emergence – new behaviour which emerges naturally and spontaneously simply as a result of the complex interactions within the system, rather than in response to specific causal factors.

Evidence from the interviews suggested that a residential experience can be understood as a complex system. Therefore the emergence of new behaviour automatically takes place. It is suggested that this leads naturally and, for some, inevitably to the transformative, non-linear step change in self-confidence that is so often seen.

If you are interested in a fuller description of complexity together with further details on the quantitative research and a link to the full study, a research summary is available from randall@avius.org

Perhaps the most tantalising finding from the research is the correlation between the impact of a course and an improvement in classroom attainment. To establish whether a residential causes that improvement would require an experimental research design with a control group. Because such a finding would be enormously useful in lobbying for greater opportunities for young people, I intend to carry out that research. If you work in a primary school that organises residentials and carries out formative assessments on a termly basis, and would be willing to spend a small amount of time getting some data together, or if you think you might be able to put me in touch with such a school, I should love to hear from you at randall@avius.org

Source
Randall Williams
Council for Learning Outside the Classroom
The impact of residential experience on primary school pupils

Randall Williams